Harper Shaw / Case Experience

Case Experience

Since its establishment in 2016, Harper Shaw Investigation Consultants Ltd has undertaken specialist examinations and provided expert assistance in a range of serious crime, collision and vehicle-related investigations.

Our instructions have included vehicle data acquisition, forensic examination, technical interpretation, independent evidence review and the preparation of expert reports for legal proceedings.

The examples below illustrate the different ways in which our expertise has contributed to investigations conducted by law enforcement agencies, solicitors, barristers and other organisations.

Case examples are limited to concluded matters and information considered appropriate for public disclosure. Certain details have been omitted or summarised to respect legal, evidential and confidentiality obligations.

Vehicle Systems Forensics

Vehicle Systems Forensics — Selected Casework

Vehicle-generated information can provide evidence relating to movements, events, system activity and connections with other devices.

Our involvement has included the recovery of data from unsupported electronic systems, independent verification of acquired records and the interpretation of technical findings within serious criminal and collision investigations.

Lancashire Police

Murder Investigation — Murder of Lenny Scott

Investigation

Lancashire Police investigated the murder of Lenny Scott, who was fatally shot in Skelmersdale in February 2024. Vehicle-generated data formed part of the technical evidence examined during the investigation.

Harper Shaw's Involvement

Lancashire Police had undertaken the principal vehicle data acquisitions. Harper Shaw provided specialist assistance with alternative acquisition methods where the initial examinations had not recovered all potentially relevant information. Our principal involvement focused on the interpretation and reliability of the recovered vehicle data, particularly timing discrepancies between recorded events and the limitations of the systems generating those records.

Evidential Contribution

Harper Shaw produced two expert reports explaining the technical findings, the potential causes of timing discrepancies and the limitations that needed to be considered when interpreting the vehicle data. The reports assisted in clarifying the evidential significance of the records for the court. Both expert reports were accepted by the defence during the trial.

The case demonstrates the importance of understanding how vehicle systems record information, particularly where timing differences could affect the interpretation of events.

West Midlands Police

Attempted Murder

Investigation

The case centred around a stolen vehicle being used to carry out a gang shooting.

Harper Shaw's Involvement

Worked with West Midlands Police to support them with Vehicle Systems Forensics. We extracted data from the infotainment module, which was unsupported by Berla.

Evidential Contribution

The examination identified a number of devices subsequently attributed to suspects and interacting with the vehicle at around the time of the shooting.

Avon & Somerset Police

Fatal Collision

Investigation

A vehicle veered across the road into oncoming traffic, colliding head on with two other vehicles and killing the occupant of the second vehicle.

Harper Shaw's Involvement

Worked with Avon & Somerset Police to retrieve speeds from the vehicle involved. The vehicle was unsupported for crash data retrieval using the Bosch CDR tools, so we checked the front facing ADAS camera for stored data, the infotainment module for journey data, and facilitated network communication to recover speeds recorded in freeze frame data on some of the ECUs.

Evidential Contribution

The speeds retrieved from the vehicle's systems were produced as an expert report and scrutinised by the defence team, who accepted the findings.

Solicitors (defence)

Murder Investigation

Investigation

The case involved a vehicle running over a pedestrian and dragging them for over half a mile under the vehicle. The vehicle was burnt out, however Police investigators recovered data from the infotainment module.

Harper Shaw's Involvement

Assisted solicitors representing a client investigated for murder. Upon instruction we reacquired the data to demonstrate it had been acquired in a sound manner, and mapped the full journey from the data and vehicle events — supported by our ongoing testing and research in this field.

Evidential Contribution

Produced an expert report. Sound interpretations of the data allowed those instructed to defend the client to fully understand the vehicle data and its reliability in this case.

Greater Manchester Police

Kidnapping Investigations

Investigation

Victims had been targeted for large sums of money. The vehicles were integral to the investigation.

Harper Shaw's Involvement

Worked with Greater Manchester Police to assist in a number of kidnappings. A number of these vehicles were examined by us.

Evidential Contribution

Significant evidence uncovered to assist the case.

These cases were documented as part of the BBC series — The Detectives — Serious Organised Crime.

Police Scotland

Murder Investigation

Investigation

Data was recovered from a vehicle used in a high profile murder.

Harper Shaw's Involvement

Assisted Police Scotland with the formulation of an expert report for the recovered vehicle data.

Evidential Contribution

The vehicle's movements and events were plotted, with full descriptions of vehicle systems documenting the source of the data and its reliability.

Barristers & the court

Murder Investigation

Investigation

A murder case dealt with in North Wales.

Harper Shaw's Involvement

Assisted barristers and the court to explain Vehicle Systems Forensics and review the prosecution material.

Evidential Contribution

Provided explanations of theft methods used for modern vehicles, and how modern vehicle apps work and communicate with the vehicle and the manufacturer.

Wider Casework

Other Vehicle-Related Investigations

Alongside Vehicle Systems Forensics examinations, Harper Shaw has undertaken specialist instructions involving vehicle identification, investigation review and the interpretation of technical evidence.

Vehicle Identification from CCTV

An execution style murder in Northern Ireland.

Provided an expert report for the identification and imagery analysis of the vehicle used. The vehicle was identified from thirty-five CCTV clips recovered by PSNI, with levels of support attributed to each clip.

Gave evidence at Belfast Crown Court where the evidence was accepted. Three defendants were found guilty after trial for murder.

Police Misconduct

A police pursuit in which the subject vehicle killed a pedestrian. The police officers pursuing the subject vehicle were the subject of investigation.

Worked with the Independent Office for Police Complaints in respect of the pursuit investigation, examining and comparing information from multiple sources.

Extensive investigation and overlaying a variety of data sources revealed the accounts were inconsistent with the facts. Disciplinary hearings were held.

Cheshire Police

Vehicle Theft Methods

A number of items recovered by Cheshire Police believed to be used in the commission of vehicle theft and key programming.

Commented on the recovered items.

Provided an expert report including explanations of relay / amplification attacks in how a modern vehicle is compromised.

Previous Police Service

Earlier Professional Experience — Serious Collision Investigation

Before establishing Harper Shaw in 2016, Noel Lowdon served with West Yorkshire Police, including seven years within its Major Collision Enquiry Team.

This work involved the investigation of fatal and serious injury road collisions across a wide range of circumstances, vehicle types and road environments.

The department investigated more than 500 fatal collisions during the relevant period, providing extensive exposure to complex collision enquiries, evidential assessment and the demands of serious investigative work.

West Yorkshire is a diverse county covering urban and rural areas with the addition of a busy motorway network, and we have worked in all these areas.

This earlier experience forms an important part of the investigative background underpinning Harper Shaw's present specialist work.

Whilst not an exhaustive list, the following are incidents we have experience of investigating:

  • Corporate manslaughter investigations
  • Fail to stop fatal collisions
  • Multiple suspects (16 in one case)
  • Multiple fatalities and injured parties
  • Single occupant, no other parties involved
  • Work related collisions involving professional drivers
  • Heavy goods vehicles
  • Police involvement and work with the IPCC
  • Cases involving other criminality, e.g. stolen vehicles
  • Disputed driver cases
  • Conspiracy to defraud
  • Pervert the course of justice

Specialist Vehicle Evidence & Independent Review

Harper Shaw continues to support serious crime, collision and other vehicle-related investigations through specialist Vehicle Systems Forensics examinations, data interpretation, independent expert review and technical investigative advice.

Discuss a Specialist Instruction

If your investigation involves vehicle-generated evidence or requires independent technical review, please contact Harper Shaw to discuss the circumstances and the assistance required.

Further information concerning relevant case experience may be available on request, subject to confidentiality and disclosure restrictions.